Timing vs. Stock-Picking

Let's face it. Buy-and-hope is long dead. We sail in a new ocean where central bank whales prop up markets and economies on one side. And high-frequency sharks rip stocks back and forth for short-term gain on the other.

Is there a way to survive in these waters? I think there is a strategy that can give you high confidence and solid returns for a part of your trading portfolio -- without the headaches and heartaches of single stock blow ups. Let's look at the challenge, and the new opportunity.


3 Major Reasons Stock-Picking is So Hard

Before we get into specific hazards of trying to beat the proverbial monkey throwing darts, let me share a set of simple market truths I've honed down to two sentences:

It is possible to beat the S&P 500 (the market benchmark) because of stock-picking skill (and luck), and the fact that the index never takes a profit.

But, it is difficult to beat the S&P 500 because of stock-picking mistakes (and company blow-ups), and the fact that the index never takes a loss.


1) Your Stocks Have Company-Specific Risk

The seduction of being a stock-picker is finding those one or two dozen companies that crush the market with 25, 50, even 100% price appreciation. It's also one of the harder games in town.

There are many reasons most portfolio managers, including actively managed mutual funds and hedge funds, don't beat the market. I just shared with you the double-edge sword they wield in search of double-digit returns. As you can see, possible doesn't make it probable.

And with thousands of companies to choose from, how do you know you can find enough of the big winners to make up for the inevitable big losers? The market ocean is full of public companies dealing with 'unknown unknowns' like surprise regulation, new competition and accounting fraud.


2) Your Stocks Are Anchored to Market and Sector Movement

No matter how great the company is that you own, no matter how superior its earnings growth and outlook, when markets tank, so do these strong stocks.

Just think of the three market corrections in each of the past three years. The bull market has remained intact, and I'd bet even the fundamental earnings picture for some of your favorite companies did too.

If you were smart and swift, you likely saw the recession-fear downdrafts coming and were able to sell high and buy back lower. But that is always a psychological battle too. When your favorite stocks are already down 5-10%, do you sell then and hope you can buy them back lower?

Even sector gyrations can turn value stocks into perpetual bargains. Just look at the moves in Energy and Technology this year. Some value stocks became even cheaper as these sectors make their big swings and a few big names were the cause of the irrational moves.