Stocks cut losses. Tariff war averted. Canada reverses energy surcharge after Trump threat

U.S. stocks closed lower, but cut their steep early losses in the afternoon after Ontario Premier Doug Ford agreed to suspend a 25% surcharge on electricity imports to Michigan, New York and Minnesota.

The backpedaling came after President Donald Trump ordered on Tuesday morning a doubling of tariffs on Canadian aluminum and steel to 50% in retaliation against Ontario’s energy duties. The 50% tariffs were to become effective Wednesday, he said. After the close, the Trump administration said the double tariff is off the table in light of Ford's retreat.

Trump's retaliation, though, was the latest in a series of escalating trade moves, including tariffs on Mexico and China, that have stoked fears of a U.S. economic recession and whipsawed markets. Economists fear a trade war also will reignite inflation that’s already struggled to drop to the Federal Reserve’s 2% goal.

Stocks went into a tailspin on Monday after Trump declined in an interview on Sunday to rule out a recession this year. Instead, he emphasized "a period of transition" that's happening.

The tech-heavy Nasdaq had sunk deeper into correction territory, which is defined as at least 10% below a record high, before rebounding after the tariff war appeared to be averted. The broad S&P 500 bounced off its correction line.

The S&P 500 index ended down 0.76%, or 42.49 points, to 5,572.07; the blue-chip Dow shed 1.14%, or 478.23 points, to 41,433.48; and the tech-heavy Nasdaq slipped 0.18%, or 32.23 points, to 17,436.10 after posting its worst day since September 2022 on Monday. The benchmark 10-year yield rose to 4.284%.

Are stock investors overreacting to tariffs?

Experts are split on what the effects of the tariffs would be on the economy. While many are penciling in lower stock values due to higher risks of a recession and elevated inflation due to a rising chance of a trade war, others say the volatile stock market needs some context.

"While the (stock) pullback has been challenging, some perspective is warranted," said Daniel Skelly, head of Morgan Stanley's wealth management market research and strategy team. "Aside from a compelling argument that the market was overdue for a downturn of this magnitude, 10% corrections usually don’t become 20% bear markets unless they’re accompanied by either an economic recession, an earnings recession, or a Fed hiking cycle. We’re not seeing any of those right now."

This morning's Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) showed the labor market continued to expand in January, for example.

"The report will probably not help markets concerned with the economy, but it is still a positive report for the U.S. labor market and for the economy," said Raymond James' Chief economist Eugenio Aleman.