Unlock stock picks and a broker-level newsfeed that powers Wall Street.

Q4 2024 Liberty Global Ltd Earnings Call

In This Article:

Participants

Michael Fries; Chief Executive Officer; Liberty Global Ltd

Charles Bracken; Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President; Liberty Global Ltd

Lutz Schüler; Chief Executive Officer, Virgin Media O2; Liberty Global Ltd

Steve Malcolm; Analyst; Redburn Atlantic

Joshua Mills; Analyst; BNP Paribas Exane

Carl Murdock-Smith; Analyst; Citigroup, Inc.

Matthew Harrigan; Analyst; The Benchmark Company

Ulrich Rathe; Analyst; Sanford C. Bernstein & Co.

David Wright; Analyst; BofA Securities

James Ratzer; Analyst; New Street Research LLP

Presentation

Operator

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to Liberty Global's fourth quarter 2024 investor call. This call and the associated webcast are the property of Liberty Global, and any redistribution, retransmission, or rebroadcast of this call or webcast in any form without the expressed written consent of Liberty Global is strictly prohibited.
(Operator Instructions) Today's formal presentation materials can be found under the Investor Relations section of Liberty Global's website at libertyglobal.com.
After today's formal presentation, instructions will be given for a question-and-answer session. Page 2 of the slides details the company's safe harbor statement regarding forward-looking statements. Today's presentation may include forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, including the company's expectations with respect to its outlook and future growth prospects and other information and statements that are not historical facts.
These forward-looking statements involve certain risks that could cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied by these statements. These risks include those detailed in Liberty Global's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including its most recently filed Forms 10-Q and 10-K as amended. Liberty Global disclaims any obligation to update any of these forward-looking statements to reflect any change in its expectations or any conditions on which any such statement is based.
I would now like to turn the call over to Mr. Mike Fries.

Michael Fries

All right, thank you, and welcome everyone to our year-end investor call. It's great to have you join us today.
I've got the core team on the line as usual, so after prepared remarks, we'll get right to your questions. And as a reminder, we always post a slide deck which has really good data and follows the narrative that Charlie and I will deliver right now. So I'm going to start on slide 3.
Most of you know who we are, and you know what we do. But it's always good, I think, to start with the big picture, especially now. 12 months ago, on this call we presented a plan to generate and importantly deliver value to our shareholders. That's exactly what we did in 2024 with over $4 billion in shareholder remuneration delivered on a market cap of $7 billion just 12 months ago.
And as we'll talk about today, this remains our primary focus. So to kick us off, I think the chart here on this slide is the simplest, least complex way to understand the business of Liberty Global today.
We consider ourselves to be a dynamic team of veteran operators and investors, committed to generating and delivering shareholder value through the strategic management of three platforms.
Liberty Telecom consists of our four remaining European telcos, you know these well, in the UK, Ireland, Belgium, and the Netherlands, serving $80 million fixed and mobile connections and generating $22 billion of aggregate revenue and around $8 billion of aggregate EBITDA. I'll talk about our strategic plans for growing and ultimately crystallizing the value of these fixed mobile champions in just a moment.
Liberty Growth represents our $3.1 billion portfolio of investments in technology, media, sports, and infrastructure, and we've grown this business substantially over the last five years. We've also been really disciplined about exiting positions at good returns and then repurposing that capital both into Liberty Telecom and additional growth investments. And then Liberty Services on the right is a hidden gem.
Over the last several years we have successfully transitioned over two-thirds of our central employee base into profitable revenue generating activities in tech and financial services. These are valuable operating divisions with long-term contracts, nearly $600 million of annual revenue, third party partnerships, and really viable strategies to continue growing and ultimately, monetizing these businesses for the benefit of shareholders.
So why make a big deal of this, you might ask? Well, when your stock is $11 and you have 350 million shares outstanding, we become hyper aware of the fact that even small opportunities like this can move the needle.
Which is a great segue to the next slide, and as I just mentioned on our year-end call last February, we renounced a clear strategic pivot, right? We outlined a game plan and at that time focused on maximizing the intrinsic value of our assets and delivering that value to shareholders. Not surprisingly, the most important initiatives, which were summarized here on slide 4, revolved around Liberty Telecom, where the GAAP in value and the upside to shareholders was and remains the largest.
The big headline was of course our commitment to spin off 100% of Sunrise, our Swiss subsidiary to Liberty Global shareholders before year end. The logic and timing of that transaction was compelling. Sunrise operates in a rational market. The company had been delivering solid operating performance driven principally by strong free cash flow and the potential for sizable dividends.
And we saw strong local investor demand to own the number one challenger to Swisscom. Now trust me, this was a complex transaction, but these are the things that this management team really excels at in fact, and the spinoff was completed on time and effectively delivered to our shareholders a $9 per share tax-free dividend and was at the time an $18 stock, and we did that by spinning off 20% of our proportionate EBITDA.
Let that sink in. Now, by all accounts, this was a success. Sunrise stock is trading well with 70% of the ADS is now converted into local Swiss shares, and we've learned a really valuable lesson on how to unlock value.
We also announced last year our intention to create a fixed Netco in the UK market to accelerate and fund a portion of our fiber build out and to provide a vehicle for what we expect will be a rapidly consolidating infrastructure market. I'm happy to report that we are making significant progress on this front. The operational and financial perimeters of the UK Netco have been established. They represent around 16 million homes and over GBP1 billion of EBITDA.
But more importantly, as of last week, we are in receipt of proposals from a handful of the strongest infrastructure investors in the business who have indicated an interest in participating with us in what will be, I think, the only viable long-term competitor to BT Openreach. So more on that to come.
And then finally we discussed the opportunity to focus our attention and resources on the Benelux region. And while the prospect of a combined Dutch and Belgian operation is intriguing, we spent most of our time last year ensuring that each business is achieving its strategic and financial potential individually, and this included hiring a new CEO for VodafoneZiggo, Stephen van Rooyen, who hit the ground running in September.
And in Belgium, where we've already separated the network from Telenet, we've made substantial progress with the Belgian government to rationalize the fiber market through a network sharing and collaboration agreement between Wyre, that's our Netco, Telenet, and Proximus. Even prior to the conclusion of that transaction, our Treasury team just closed on a EUR500 million standalone facility for Wyre's fiber rollout. That just supports the attractiveness of this market opportunity.
Now, in addition to our objectives for Liberty Telecom, we also announced a series of other key goals last year, and those are listed on slide 5 that we knew would anchor our value creation strategies.
At the Liberty Global level, we committed to buying back up to 10% of our shares outstanding, and we spent approximately $700 million doing that. As a reminder, we have now spent roughly $15 billion over the last eight years to acquire over 60% of our shares. Now, obviously, we believe in the multiplier effect of stock buybacks. For example, if you owned 1% of Liberty Global in 2017, you ended up with 2.5% of Sunrise at the spinoff date.
We also committed to refinance all of our 2027 maturities in the Liberty Telecom debt silos, and we did that with over $3 billion in re-fis at Vodafone and VMO2. Now Charlie will get into more detail, but our balance sheet remains rock solid.
And we achieved all14 of our financial guidance metrics with the exception of one, which is related to VodafoneZiggo revenue, where we had guided to growth but came in flat due to slower mobile net ads and a lower mobile handset sale number.
To implement our strategic goals, we also committed to sell assets amounting to $500 million to $1billion dollars in 2024. That number came in at $900 million and together with free cash flow, helped fund the buyback and deleveraging at Sunrise to maximize the equity value of the spin for shareholders.
And we articulated a clear preference to prioritize future investments in Liberty Growth around scale-based platforms with tailwinds, and of course the best example here is the acquisition of our controlling interest in Formula E, which I'll talk about in just a moment.
Now, here's the kicker. Despite hitting the mark on the strategic goals in 2024, Liberty Global shares proforma for the spinoff of Sunrise, remain significantly undervalued. I'll walk you through how we see it on slide 6, which lays out a pretty simple sum of the parts analysis. Some investors like it when we just get down to the brass tacks, as they say, and this is how we run the business. So here you go.
The first key point to make on this chart is that we think our stock today assigns zero equity value to Liberty Telecom. How do we get to that conclusion? Well, the first three columns here show our cash balance and the combined fair market value of our Liberty Growth portfolio.
And that adds up to about $15 per share. And then we assume an appropriate reduction for corporate of $4 per share, which we'll dive into later. But with that you essentially get to a market price of $11 per share. So what is the right value for Liberty Telecom? The blue bar there. There are many ways to approach this, as you know all too well, but the Sunrise spin demonstrated the potential uplift in trading multiples when you find the right transaction or market opportunity.
Case in point, as part of Liberty Global, Sunrise traded essentially at our combined and current multiple of 5.5 times EBITDA. As a listed company in Switzerland, Sunrise trades at 8 times EBITDA or a 78% dividend yield.
Now assuming every operating company, should be worth 8 times, that might be ambitious, right? But if you assume a conservative one multiple uplift in the value of Liberty Telecom, say from 5.5 to 6.5 times EBITDA, by the way, which is the EU telco sector average and where most analysts have us, then you arrive at $14 per share for Liberty Telecom alone.
Now we've certainly shown you higher numbers for Liberty Telecom in the past, but given what we're trading, today we're happy to be conservative. Adding all that up gets you to $25 per share for Liberty Global, and that's before signing any equity value for Liberty Services. We're not putting a number on that today, but I can tell you it's greater than $0. Then lastly, this compares to average analysts price targets of around $14.60.
Now one of the big differences is, is the deduction of corporate, which is typically twice the number we're using but completely neglects the fact that these net central costs are nearly 100% variable OpEx and should be valued on an EBITDA multiple. More on that from Charlie. At this point, the question you should be asking is how do we intend to continue bridging this gap.
We try to address that on slide 7 with a summary of our strategic plan for 2025 and beyond, and as you just saw, there is significant upside to improving the real or perceived value of Liberty Telecom. Just one additional EBITDA multiple, more than doubles our stocks. So not surprisingly, we believe there will be opportunities to crystallize or monetize the value of Liberty Telecom's businesses over time.
Like summarize, this could include spinoffs, although, as many of this decision is dependent on several tax, legal, and financial factors. We could also consider tracking stocks, IPOs, and of course, we always remain open to M&A options. To achieve any of these though, we need to pursue three tactical steps.
Number one, we have to continue to drive commercial momentum at the operating level. This is the primary objective of every local management team. They are all focused on expanding loyalty programs to reduce churn, promoting robust flanker brands to drive market share, realizing the benefits of digital and AI accelerating, B2B, and rolling out new revenue streams.
Second, we'll continue to creatively finance our fixed network infrastructure, particularly in the UK, Belgium, and Ireland, where our fiber plans are well underway. These infrastructure assets trade at higher multiples, attract a unique type of investor, and can absorb more leverage than what we are typically seeing on ServeCos. So we want to take advantage of these factors, and we will.
And third, our ability to achieve greater value recognition at Liberty Telecom will to a large extent be dependent on generating free cash flow, especially free cash flow that can be used for dividends. So the Sunrise model demonstrated this clearly. As a result, we're squarely focused on achieving this goal over the next 24 to 36 months.
Now moving to Liberty Growth, our plans take two forms. On the one hand, we recognize that many of the assets we own today are non-core, and as we demonstrated in 2024, can be highly accretive sources of cash for more strategic opportunities.
So as a result, we will continue to rotate capital into higher return Liberty Growth assets, prioritizing infrastructure, sports, and media, as well as into strategic Liberty Telecom transactions. Towards that end, we are committing today to sell between $500 million and $750 million of non-core assets in 2025.
And then finally, our cash balance of $2.2 billion is a significant strategic asset. Our primary use here will be for buybacks, the leveraging, and the investments described above. Specifically, we're committing to buying up to 10% of our shares outstanding in 2025 as we did last year, and we anticipate that our cash balance will be replenished with free cash flow and dividends from Liberty Telecom, asset sales, and infrastructure financing.
And to round it off, Charlie will talk about our Liberty Services platform and corporate spending in a moment. I'll just say watch this space. Both of these are expected to be meaningful contributors to our value creation narrative.
Now turning to the next slide, I'll just spend a minute on our Q4 operating results. You would have reviewed these already, and we do have the OpCo leads on the call. The punch line here is that we're seeing steady or improved broadband results with continued fixed ARPU uplifts in most of our markets, and we also saw a small pickup and postpaid mobile, particularly in the UK.
Sticking with VMO2, the UK saw another strong broadband quarter of 12,000 net ads that was supported by new homes in the nexfibre territory and really good base management. All of this despite aggressive alt-net pricing and what looks like a flat broadband market overall. It was also the third straight quarter of fixed ARPU growth in the UK, reflecting materially better retention as a result of our digital and AI tools.
And VMO2 also saw a significant turnaround in postpaid mobile throughout the year. We lost nearly 200,000 subs in the first half of the year and we're essentially flat in the second half with a positive net add quarter in Q4. We contribute this to two things, I think strong results from Giffgaff, our flanker brand, and success in underpinning the premium position of O2.
Now some quick remarks in Ireland. This is a small operation with largely stable results, but we want to start adding this to the narrative here. Virgin Media Ireland is the farthest along on the fiber transformation, with around half of our 1 million premises already upgraded, almost 50,000 fiber customers on our network, including Vodafone and Sky wholesale customers.
Now while CapEx will remain elevated in 2025, we should be largely done with the bill by the end of this year, early next year, and like many European telcos, the decline in CapEx should drive meaningful free cashflow over the long run.
Turning to the Netherlands, we saw intense competition in the Dutch broadband market continue where loss was mostly price led in Q4. Now VodafoneZiggo remains focused on value over volume with largely flat ARPU in the quarter.
On the positive front, UEFA rights are driving uptake across different channels, including through Ziggo Sport. The Dutch mobile market is more rational but has seen lots of price competition in the no frills segment. Nonetheless, we have delivered stable net ads as the impact from B2B port out stabilized and FMC Sims penetration continued to increase.
And then lastly on Telenet, they returned to positive broadband net ads for the first time in two years in the fourth quarter, and that was underpinned by successful fixed mobile convergence campaigns, including the new base proposition, which is exceeding expectations. The fixed ARPU growth continue to be supported by the price rise earlier this year in mobile postpaid to decrease modestly in the quarter driven by challenging market dynamics.
So two more slides on Liberty Growth before I turn it over to Charlie. Understandably, we get a lot of questions about the portfolio and hopefully our disclosures this quarter and in future quarters will demonstrate that we are committed to providing greater transparency and information to you, especially as this becomes a bigger part of our evaluation story. Towards that end, slide 9 provides two important pieces of data.
First, on the left, you'll see our investment activity over the last five years in the aggregate. At the end of 2019, so five years ago, our investment assets to around $900 million in what we now call Liberty Growth. Between 2019 and the end of 2024, we invested an additional $2.4 billion in our tech media and infrastructure verticals, plus some strategic holdings.
During that same period, however, we also exited investments that returned $1.2 billion to us, including dividends, with a weighted average IRR of 25%. Now this includes the good and the bad deals, so this is a true measure of those disposals. That left us with net invested capital in the portfolio at the end of last year 2024 of $2.1 billion compared to a fair market value on our 10-K of $3.1 billion. That valuation, by the way, is independently reviewed by Deloitte and breaks down between tech, media, infrastructure, et cetera as shown in the color legend at the bottom.
So we're sitting on a billion dollars of unrealized gains in the portfolio today. I already mentioned that we intend to generate between $500 million and $750 million in sale proceeds this year, a significant portion of which will likely come from Liberty Growth. Now Liberty Growth is a diversified portfolio with investments in upwards of 70 different companies. I get that that creates some complexity for you, but on the right-hand side, we make the important point that 75% of our portfolio resides in just seven investments. And we list those here.
This includes three media holdings: Formula E, ITV, and Televisa Univision; three infrastructure investments: AtlasEdge, EdgeConnex, and nexfibre, and our stake in Vodafone. Now we're not discouraging you from focusing on the balance of our investments, but I do think it makes it simpler when we present it like this, and these are the assets that you'll be hearing about, we'll be talking about, and that more often than not will be driving our returns.
Now I'll end on a super high note. I think everyone knows we increased our stake in Formula E to 66% last year when we bought out Warner Brothers Discovery, and I have to say I couldn't be more excited about that transaction and where this championship is going. Slide 10 just hits a few of the key points, the key highlights, beginning on the top left with the car itself.
When we first invested in Formula E, we made a bet on technology innovation, and that bet is paying off. The first-generation car topped out at 140 mph and really couldn't drive very far. We are now in what we call the Gen 3 EVO car, and it is a rocket ship.
It has speeds capable of 200 mph, and the car accelerates 30% faster than an F1 car 0 to 60 in just 1.82 seconds.
And we have the Gen 4 car coming out in just 18 months' time, which aims to double the power. I think the point is that these cars are lightning fast, no pun intended, and the racing is more and more exciting every year.
As you can see on the top right, we already raced in some of the most iconic cities in the world, places like Sao Paulo, Mexico City, Jeddah, Miami, Monaco, Tokyo, Shanghai, Jakarta, Berlin, and London. And with a faster car and longer races, we expect to gain access to even more tracks and venues.
And even though we've been net zero since day zero, this is all about the racing, right? It's no surprise to me, it shouldn't be to you that we've attracted some of the world's greatest racing brands including Porsche, Jaguar, McLaren, Maserati, Nissan, Penske, Andretti, and others.
They're part of this global championship because they see the future and the potential. By 2035, nearly 70% of global car sales are expected to be electric vehicles, and we have an exclusive on this racing series with the FAA, who, by the way, are great partners of ours for many years to come.
Then finally, word is getting out. We're now at roughly 400 million fans globally, and that's growing 23%. You'll also see on the bottom left that while there are two championships with bigger audiences today, F1 and MotoGP, neither is growing as fast.
Remember, we're a very young championship, at least compared to Formula 1, which is 75 years old, but the ceiling feels -- seems unlimited. So stay tuned for more updates on what is now a consolidated asset, Formula E, and Charlie, with that, I'll send it over to you.