Russian president Vladimir Putin is running out of friends in Europe and Western Asian, and he plainly wants to keep those who remain close. On Friday, he proposed that Russia, Kazakhstan, and Belarus form a currency union – a situation similar to that in in the Eurozone, in which all three nations would use a common medium of exchange.
Putin on Friday met with Belarussian President Alexander Lukashenko and Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev. After the meeting, he told reporters, "The time has come to start thinking about forming a currency union."
Related: Putin Again Begs Oligarchs to Bring Their Money Home
Neither Lukashenko nor Nazarbayev commented on the question of combining with Russia under a single currency, but it seems safe to say that they are likely to be dubious at best.
The benefits of a joint currency would include removing foreign exchange risk on the substantial trade among the three countries, which at the beginning of the year formed the Eurasian Economic Union (other participants include Armenia and, eventually Kyrgyzstan).
The EEU, sort of a junior version of the European Union, removed many restrictions on cross-border trade and allows free cross-border travel for citizens of member states. The elimination of exchange risk is no small matter at a time when the Russian ruble has lost about 40 percent of its value due to international sanctions related to the Russian invasion of Ukraine’s Crimean peninsula and its support of rebels in eastern Ukraine.
To see the potential dangers of such a Union, particularly one in which one partner is dominant, the presidents of Belarus and Kazakhstan need only look to the southwest to see what is currently happening to Greece.
Related: Putin Takes His Wacky War Games One Step Further
The Greek economy was not in great shape when the Great Recession hit, which crippled the country with debt. It never implemented a rigorous tax collection system and growth initiatives that could have immunized the country against collapse. Today, Greece is still struggling to recover.
Germany, on the other hand, is disciplined on all counts and is the dominant economy in the Eurozone. It long resisted measures that might have eased the pain of its weaker neighbors, including lowering interest rates as the U.S. Federal Reserve bank did with considerable success.
There is no doubt about who would be the dominant partner in such an arrangement. Even given the tough economic times it has been facing, Russia’s $3.6 trillion economy in 2014 was more than six times the size of the combined economies of Kazakhstan’s ($420.6 billion) and Belarus’s ($176.9 billion).