The shelling of the market by cornered, forced sellers has quieted for the moment. But is it a lasting truce, or are they simply re-loading?
Yesterday in some respects was a missed opportunity for a nice “turnaround Tuesday” bounce in stocks. The S&P 500 (^GSCP) had a nasty Monday and was again looking stretched to the downside, with bleak investor attitudes and Carl Icahn’s doomsday market call serving as what could’ve been an ideal ironic Buy signal.
Yet the early rally mostly fizzled, credit markets stayed squishy, bank stocks kept bleeding and biotechs stayed under pressure.
Still, the relative calm yesterday and the return of several key market gauges to the low of Aug. 24 is prompting debate over whether this might have been a proper, low-drama “retest” of these earlier market depths. Today’s decent early bounce in indexes will intensify this argument.
The Russell 2000 (^RUT) small-cap gauge undercut the Aug. 24 level. The equal-weighted version of the S&P 500, a measure of the “typical stock” that’s traded under Guggenheim S&P 500 Equal-Weight ETF (RSP), closed lower than it finished that day. And the intensity of the stock purge eased somewhat, with lower trading volumes and less-urgent demand for downside protection.
The reason market watchers are parsing the coded messages of the tape so closely is this: The line between bull and bear market is nearby to us, and fine enough to cross without really noticing.
This is, at least, a mature bull market that will surrender the benefit of the doubt if it fails to rally amid putrid investor sentiment and global easy money for much longer.
Of course, the majority of stocks have already dropped 20% from their highs, so the semantics of what to call the market are perhaps beside the point. But it matters a lot to those wanting to stay in the market or add to investments now or later.
The market is not cheap, but is a lot cheaper than it was. It certainly could keep dropping, to price in diminished growth prospects, but nothing says it needs to. The Fed’s likely course of action is no clearer today than a few days ago, but no more obscure either.
The market is simply responding to the fact that, near inflection points, the prospect of some policy error inherently rises. Two years ago there was worry that, having passed on a chance to ease back on QE in September it would never do so – yet it did, in December, and it was fine.
Get the Latest Market Data and News with the Yahoo Finance App
Meantime, deflationary data in Europe has spurred louder talk of more easy money there, so who knows what policy cues will matter first.