In This Article:
(Bloomberg) -- The venture capital model honed and perfected in Silicon Valley is proving a bad fit for the clean tech industry, and investors should instead accept that they’ll need to commit much bigger sums of money for longer periods of time.
Most Read from Bloomberg
-
Billionaire Steve Cohen Wants NY to Expand Taxpayer-Backed Ferry
-
LA City Council Passes Budget That Trims Police, Fire Spending
“In traditional VC, the model is to make 100 bets, 90 of which will completely fail, and of the 10 remaining maybe a couple will have real exponential growth,” JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s Rama Variankaval said in an interview. However, “the amount of capital you’d need to replicate that in climate is enormous, so you might need to accept a revised model where you are picking fewer, more concentrated bets.”
The warning from Variankaval, whose role as global head of corporate advisory includes running JPMorgan’s Center for Carbon Transition, has serious implications for the trajectory of climate change. More than $200 trillion needs to be invested in the transition to net zero over the next three decades to avoid catastrophic temperature rises, BloombergNEF estimates. Spending last year, meanwhile, was just over $2 trillion.
Most of the money — both public and private — flowing into the low-carbon transition is going toward electrified transport, renewable energy and power grids, BNEF’s analysis shows.
Those are capital-intensive sectors that require committed capital. That’s in contrast to the “asset-light businesses” to which venture capital is best suited, Variankaval said.
“If you are investing in a software business and you put in $10 million, the need for additional capital from this company might not be high,” Variankaval said. “But $10 million in a climate tech company doesn’t get you a whole lot of runway.”
Of the $270 billion of energy transition-focused private capital raised between 2017 and 2022, venture capital accounted for $120 billion, or 43%, while private equity and infrastructure-focused funds raised $100 billion, or 37%, according to a September 2023 report by S2G, a firm that focuses on venture and growth-stage businesses.
Fresh examples include climate tech investment firm Energize Capital, which just raised $430 million for a new fund targeting early-stage startups working on projects like new batteries and software for the electric grid.
Clean tech was particularly vulnerable to the rapid surge in interest rates that started in early 2022, with much of the capital-intensive green sector brought to its knees in the period that followed. Over the past three years, the S&P Global Clean Energy Transition Index has lost almost 40% of its value, compared with a gain of more than 40% in the S&P 500 Index.