You can’t take a hand grenade back after you’ve thrown it, but FBI Director James Comey gave it a try on Sunday. In an unexpected letter to members of Congress, Comey said that his agents had completed their investigation into recently uncovered Hillary Clinton emails, and that the review did not change the agency’s earlier decision to not recommend charges be brought against the Democratic presidential nominee.
It was a little more than a week ago that Comey upended the presidential race by informing members of Congress that thousands of emails had been discovered on a laptop belonging to former Rep. Anthony Weiner, the estranged husband of Clinton aide Huma Abedin. In announcing the existence of the emails, which his agency had not yet reviewed, Comey appeared to break with Justice Department protocol, which directs that investigators and prosecutors not release sensitive information immediately before an election.
Related: Has Trump Put Michigan and Minnesota in Play? Probably Not
It’s unclear just how much damage the original Comey letter did to Clinton. The presidential race appeared to be tightening for a number of reasons even prior to Comey’s announcement. There is little doubt, though, that the introduction of new uncertainty about Clinton’s legal status in the final two weeks of the presidential race was a serious drag on her candidacy just as remaining undecided voters were seriously trying to make up their minds.
Many of those who used the new information as part of their decision-making process may have already cast a vote based on it. Economist David Rothschild, who analyzes polling and elections data, estimates that because early voting is under way, as many as one-third of all votes in the election were cast in the nine days following Comey’s first letter.
The renewed investigation raised questions about whether the new emails might contain evidence of criminal wrongdoing by Clinton or her staff, and led to a barrage of leaks from the FBI that included details about what was said to be an ongoing investigation into the Clinton Foundation.
Many of the stories that grew out of the furor about the new trove of emails — particularly the claim that an indictment related to the Clinton Foundation was imminent — turned out to be false. That didn’t stop Republican nominee Donald Trump and his surrogates from declaring Clinton preemptively guilty and promising that criminal charges were on the way. The GOP nominee was still doing so as late as Sunday afternoon, at a rally in Minnesota.
Related: Gary Johnson’s Fading Run Could Be the Margin of Victory for Clinton or Trump
Clinton campaign spokesman Brian Fallon, shortly after the new letter was released, tweeted, “We were always confident nothing would cause the July decision to be revisited. Now Director Comey has confirmed it.”