3 Surprising Social Security Moves That Could Shrink Your Benefits

Social Security can go a long way toward enjoying a comfortable retirement, especially if your savings are falling short. Nearly 60% of current retirees say their benefits are a major source of income, according to a 2023 poll from Gallup, so it's wise to maximize your monthly payments.

While much of your benefit amount is determined by factors largely beyond your control, there are a few moves that can affect the size of your checks. If you're looking to earn as much as possible from Social Security, you may want to avoid these three things that could shrink your benefits.

Person standing inside looking out a window.
Image source: Getty Images.

1. Not working for 35 years

The Social Security Administration calculates your benefit amount by taking an average of your wages throughout the 35 highest-earning years of your career. That number is then run through a complex formula and adjusted for inflation, and the result is your basic benefit amount.

If you begin claiming before you've worked 35 full years, you'll have zeros included in your average to account for the time you were not working. This will bring down your average and lower your benefit amount.

You don't necessarily have to work 35 years to receive Social Security. In fact, most people become eligible for retirement benefits after working and paying Social Security taxes for 10 years. But to receive as much as possible, you'll need to have worked for at least 35 years.

2. Working after claiming

It's possible to continue working after taking Social Security, but depending on your wages, it could reduce your benefits.

If you haven't yet reached your full retirement age (FRA), you'll be subject to the retirement earnings test. This is essentially an income limit that determines how much, if any, of your benefits will be withheld due to your wages. There are two different limits, depending on whether you will or will not reach your FRA in 2024:

Situation

Income Limit

Benefit Reduction

If you will not reach your FRA in 2024

$22,320 per year

$1 for every $2 over the limit

If you will reach your FRA in 2024

$59,520 per year

$1 for every $3 over the limit

Data source: Social Security Administration. 

So, for instance, say you're 65 years old with an FRA of age 67, and you're working part-time earning $30,000 per year. You won't reach your FRA this year, so you'll be subject to the $22,320 annual limit. Your wages are $7,680 over that limit, so your benefits will be reduced by $3,840 per year, or $320 per month.

The good news is that once you reach your FRA, your income will no longer affect your benefits. Also, the Social Security Administration will recalculate your benefit amount to account for the money that was withheld due to your earnings, and you'll start receiving larger checks.