When new hires don’t work out, they end up costing companies a lot of money. This can be especially hurtful in a small-business environment. Making a bad hiring decision not only hurts your business’s bottom line, it has a negative impact on your employees and your company’s culture.
But how do you know which candidate is a good fit for your business? Matthew Bellows, CEO of Yesware, a software firm that provides cloud-based email analytics for salespeople, says you should look past the resume and interview process and imagine people working at your firm. Will they get along with other employees? If they don’t have a certain skill, are they smart enough to learn as they go?
Bellows, who has worked at six different startups, shares the three biggest mistakes he has seen employers make when hiring workers:
1. Ignoring culture fit. Too often, hiring managers will choose candidates because they have the right skills and experience, but Bellows says there should be a higher standard placed on personality fit.
“[Small-business candidates] don’t get denied because they lack a technical skill. If they’re smart enough, they’ll figure out the skill sets they need,” Bellows says. “However, we spend so much time with one another, especially in a small-business environment, that if they don’t get along with others, it’s a big deal.”
In a startup culture, a potential hire needs to be able to handle what Bellows calls “constant inevitable chaos.” One example is changing a meeting location at the last minute because of an office renovation. A good employee has to be able to handle the chaos.
2. Hiring people because they’re well-known. The problem with the “rock star” hire is that you think since they’ve already succeeded in the past, they’ll automatically succeed with you, Bellows says. But this isn’t always the case, especially if their personality doesn’t fit with your company’s culture.
“These rock stars think they’ll be running the company and you’ll end up having to bend the rules just for them. These people are expensive and have high expectations, and that isn’t always a good thing for your company.” Before you decide to commit to an expensive hire, consider the people as well as the skills they will bring to the position. Would you hire them if they didn’t have the well-known name? If not, think twice whether their “name” is enough of a reason to bring them on board.
3. Hiring the sales team before you’re ready. Bellows tells us “this is a very common error, because small businesses will look around and think that what they need to succeed is customers,” and the solution to getting customers is hiring salespeople. Although this may seem rational, when you hire salespeople before your product is scalable, you’ll run into major issues, he says.