Olympic golf returns after 112 years at a critical time for the sport

On Thursday morning in Rio, golf returned to the Olympics for the first time in 112 years. It is a return mired in controversy and discord, and some see it as a crucial opportunity for the future of the sport.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) voted back in 2009 to bring back men’s and women’s golf for the 2016 and 2020 Summer Games, which means that regardless of what happens in Rio, golf will be back for Tokyo. Its status beyond 2020 is less certain.

Earlier this summer, a rush of top golfers all dropped out of the Olympics in a hurry—nearly 20 of them in just four months, including the top four golfers in the world: Jason Day (Australia), Dustin Johnson (USA), Jordan Spieth (USA) and Rory McIlroy (Ireland).

The top-ranked golfer to compete in Rio will be Henrik Stenson, No. 5 in the world, who just won the British Open last month. The American squad consists of Bubba Watson, Rickie Fowler, Patrick Reed, and Matt Kuchar.

Many of the golfers who declined to go to Rio cited concerns about the Zika virus, but not all of them, and the consensus in the golf world was that Zika wasn’t the only reason not to go, and for many, not the true reason at all. Rather, many believe that top golfers simply weren’t interested in playing at the Olympics.

That may sound strange—what athlete wouldn’t want to go to the Olympics? But consider this: Golfers won’t be paid for going; the PGA Tour schedule is packed with lucrative tournaments just before and after the Olympics; the structure for Olympic golf is no different from any other PGA Tour event or Major (72 holes, individual play), which many fans find disappointing; PGA Tour events are already international competitions, with golfers from every country; and this year’s Olympics are in a city with far more problems than just Zika, from crime to pollution to lodging problems. It’s not shocking that so many golfers would pass on the opportunity.

Dueling stories at Golf Magazine make the case for and against Olympic golf. ESPN radio host Mike Greenberg railed on his show, “There is absolutely no earthly reason that golf should be an Olympic sport. There is not a single player in the world who would sooner win Olympic gold in golf than one of the Majors or frankly, probably any of the other events on the PGA Tour.” SportsCenter anchor Scott Van Pelt called Olympic golf “a disaster.” And Rory McIlroy himself, in an already infamous press conference, said bluntly that he won’t even watch the event on television.

Golf is struggling. It is not by any means dead—don’t believe it when you see that written. Rounds of golf played in America were up 1.8% for 2015, according to the National Golf Foundation. It was the first year of growth since 2012. Rounds played were up 3% this year as of June. This is an encouraging data point.