Orcel Escalates Commerzbank Fight With Surprise Stake Boost
(Bloomberg) -- UniCredit SpA Chief Executive Officer Andrea Orcel moved to more than double the lender’s stake in Commerzbank AG, in a dramatic development that’s likely to escalate tensions with the German government.
Most Read from Bloomberg
UniCredit said Monday that it had bought derivatives contracts for an 11.5% stake in Commerzbank, enabling it to add to the 9% of the bank that it already owns. The step effectively makes UniCredit the largest shareholder ahead of the German government and potentially puts it on course for a takeover.
The move is almost certain to exacerbate tensions between Orcel, one of Europe’s most prolific dealmakers who surprised markets this month by saying he’s considering an acquisition of Commerzbank, and the German government, which has indicated it opposes a deal. Late Friday, Berlin announced that it will pause a planned disposal of its stake in Commerzbank, with some officials apparently blindsided by Orcel’s approach.
“We do not support a takeover,” an official for the Finance Ministry said Monday. “We have communicated this to UniCredit.”
Germany still owns about 12% of Commerzbank.
Commerzbank shares fell 2.7% at 4:29 p.m. in Frankfurt, while UniCredit declined 2.6% in Milan. The German bank is up about 2% since UniCredit first disclosed its stake almost two weeks ago, while the Italian rival gained about 3%.
The drama now unfolding started in early September, when Germany announced a plan to sell about 4.5% of Commerzbank, in a first step toward returning the lender to full private ownership. The government had envisioned a sale to a range of institutional investors, arguing the lender had turned the corner and was strong enough to stand on its own feet.
Instead, UniCredit snapped up the entire holding by outbidding rivals, disclosing that it had previously amassed more shares of Commerzbank quietly in the market. The move irked German officials who said it lacked transparency, a person familiar with the matter has said, asking not to be identified discussing government deliberations.
Friedrich Merz, the leader of Germany’s main opposition party, said Monday that the government had “lost control” of the Commerzbank transaction. “There are many questions that we have for the government,” he said.
Commerzbank’s management board is convening for a strategy meeting in the Taunus hills near Frankfurt. Management is scheduled to present its vision to the bank’s supervisory board there on Tuesday and Wednesday, but Unicredit’s move is expected to be the talk of the gathering, according to people familiar with the matter.
“We consider this to be a completely inappropriate aggressive act,” said Stefan Wittmann, a representative of the trade union ver.di who sits on Commerzbank’s supervisory board. The union encourages the labor side to reject Unicredit’s approach “now more than ever” and to fight for an independent Commerzbank. “We expect the same from our government,” he told Bloomberg.
Commerzbank said in a statement Monday that it will continue to “examine strategic options” in the interests of stakeholders.
The additional 11.5% stake UniCredit disclosed on Monday is linked to derivatives, which means that the Italian bank has the right to take ownership of the shares in the future. UniCredit, which currently doesn’t have regulatory clearance to raise its stake beyond 10%, has submitted a request to increase its stake to as much as 29.9%.
It’s a strategy Orcel also used to buy around 4.5% in Commerzbank ahead of the government share sale this month. UniCredit purchased derivatives known as total return swaps for an 1.7% stake, a filing shows. That helped the Italian lender stay below 3% in physical holdings and avoid triggering a shareholder notification that would have tipped off Berlin and the competition to Orcel’s intentions.
In its statement, UniCredit cited the recent report on European competitiveness presented by former European Central Bank President Mario Draghi, arguing that the continent needs the banking consolidation that the possible takeover bid represents.
“UniCredit believes that there is substantial value that can be unlocked within Commerzbank, either stand alone or within UniCredit, for the benefit of Germany and the bank’s wider stakeholders,” it added.
Orcel has repeatedly made repeatedly clear that he remains open-minded with regard to what happens next to its stake. He has also said that at least some in Berlin were aware of his bank’s intentions, and emphasized in recent days that he’s not interested in pursuing a hostile takeover.
“Given this position, we believe the market will now fear a potentially more complex evolution of the UniCredit - Commerzbank situation and will question UniCredit’s previous statements on future intentions,” analysts including Azzurra Guelfi at Citigroup Inc. in London wrote in a note. “Ultimately we believe UniCredit will only progress on a full takeover if they are confident on the eventual return.”
--With assistance from Kamil Kowalcze.
(Updates with comment from finance ministry official in fourth paragraph, shares in sixth, union comment in 11th.)
Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek
Palantir’s CEO and Wall Street Annoy Each Other Straight to the Bank
Five Reasons to Be Optimistic About the Entertainment Business
Xbox’s President on Handheld Consoles and Subscription Gaming
©2024 Bloomberg L.P.